AWW game #38 - Horus Heresy Reboot - HORUS WINS!

[OneEye]

Away you go with Day 2. I will call it Thursday 7pm SA time.

[Virral]

Ok thats interesting I wonder why the wolf left whitetail alive? Either a snafu involving healing or a deliberate ploy to throw suspicion I guess.

Burn is the wolf, im sure of it. He didnt think his vote was needed to break a tie, therefore he claims villager not leader.

I am a villager, white is healer leaving sindex as leader and burn as the wolf.

And yes that is assuming you believe me. Im equally likely to be the wolf so it comes to a 50/50 between me and burn.

[SinisterDexter]

Wow! That 's definitely odd. Didn't burn claim as healer? If that's the case, why didn't the wolf kill him?

Do you think orchestrating a tie is useful Virral? If so, whom do you suggest votes for who?

[SinisterDexter]

Huh! Now I'm even more confused. Burn isn't healer, it's whitetail, so why didn't the wolf get HIM?!?!?

[Virral]

My best guess is that the wolf tried to take out the leader instead, who was then saved by whitetail. If so it was poorly thought out.

Note to OneEye: the healer normally chooses someone to protect (which may or may not include themselves depending on rules). By giving the healer the ability to choose to heal wolfs target you are giving them too much power. It means the healer knows who is safe (because they saved them from death) and stops the wolf from killing anyone until the healer is dead.

Burn has essentially claimed villager, which is also my claim. If he turns around to claim leader or healer now I think that would just incriminate him further. His best chance is to claim villager, push for me to be lynched first and then hope to win the following day.

Question for one eye: let's say everyone but wolf and healer are dead. Wolf eats Healer automatically?

[OneEye]

Note to OneEye: the healer normally chooses someone to protect (which may or may not include themselves depending on rules). By giving the healer the ability to choose to heal wolfs target you are giving them too much power. It means the healer knows who is safe (because they saved them from death) and stops the wolf from killing anyone until the healer is dead.

No it doesn't as the healer bio clearly states it's only usable once. It has been burnt now and so the healer is a basic villager now (just can't become a leader). By burning the heal ability it has given the wolf some very useful information to work with. It was put in place in order to give the game some more time as it would have been over in under two day sessions.

Right now the game is poised very delicately. The healer skill has opened doors everywhere but I don't feel it's OP at all.

Question for one eye: let's say everyone but wolf and healer are dead. Wolf eats Healer automatically?

This is an issue for the good guys as it would be a 50/50 vote with no tiebreaker so my advice? Don't let it happen

[Virral]

I thought the tie break keeps transferring so if the healer is now a villager couldnt it go to them?

[OneEye]

wouldnt that make him too powerful like you suggested before?

[Virral]

Hey it was your phrasing not mine.

[OneEye]

yeah it was meant to say "basically a villager" not "a basic villager"

[whitetailscramblers]

Ok so I missed the can heal one murdered or lynched player.

But I decided not to heal Joe as I had no way of knowing if he was the wolf with a lucky lynch from us, and saved burn from the wolf.

So now looking at things

Me = Villager
Burn = Villager / hero?
Joe - villager (dead)
Sindex = unknown
Virral = unknown

I vote that we focus on either Sindex or Virral. It will take me a bit of time rereading the pages to see who I feel is out of place.

[whitetailscramblers]

burn who do you feel is playing the game a bit?

[Virral]

Question for OneEye: Can the wolf target himself to be killed overnight?

[Virral]

If the answer is no then obviously burn is clear and it's down to Sindex and myself. I looked back and I actually misunderstood or misremembered burns statement. I thought he soft claimed villager, but really that's not the case from what he said so my bad there.

I guess the first thing we need is for the leader to claim. Assuming no counter claim, that will eliminate one of the possible suspects, leaving us with a firm 50/50 choice.

I thought that Sindex was the leader, and he didn't say anything to contradict me. I'm interested to see him outright confirm or deny his role.

[whitetailscramblers]

Question for OneEye: Can the wolf target himself to be killed overnight?

That was an excellent question and one that ran through my head. And if so super clever to the wolf if the answer is yes as they must have assumed that one would save the wolf attack and not the lynch.

But if they can't kill themselves we have a 50/50 lynch.

[Virral]

Either way we will have a 50/50, we just need the leader to claim. Hint: its not me

[OneEye]

Nope can't kill himself

[whitetailscramblers]

So is it the silent sindex or is virral just on the ball quicker and laying the ground work.

[SinisterDexter]

I'm not the leader either, and I've hardly been "silent". I have been smacked around at work over the last couple of days though.

Considering where we're at I think Virral is correct, although until burn claims properly as the leader I can't be sure whether the wolf is burn or Virral. Either way, it'll be the three of us on the block until that claim is made, and the two remaining afterward. It really just comes down to burn (if leader) and whitetail making a gut decision about me or Virral. I don't think you two can do better than a 50:50 crapshoot.

[whitetailscramblers]

Burn I just cant put my finger on it but i have this feeling that sindex is sus?

Your thoughts?